Tips for Finding the Right Hires to Actually Hit Your Sales Numbers
Most business owners know the gut-deep frustration of watching a promising sales or marketing plan stall out for lack of execution. You can feel the potential humming under the surface, but something’s not clicking. Usually, it’s not your vision that’s the problem. It’s the people—more specifically, not having the right external people helping you drive the thing forward. Hiring out isn't just about plugging gaps anymore, it’s about choosing people who shape your brand, sharpen your message, and close the distance between you and your next quarter’s goals.
Forget Resumes, Find Relevance
One of the most common mistakes owners make when hiring outside help is relying too heavily on resumes and buzzword-laced credentials. You don’t need the hottest name on LinkedIn or the agency with the slickest site. You need people who’ve done work like yours, in situations that mirror your current challenges. Look for relevance, not prestige. If someone helped a business half your size triple leads with half your budget, that's gold, even if they’ve never worked with a big-name brand. Don’t underestimate the value of scrappy experience with proven results over glossy reputations.
Keep Format Consistent, Keep Work Flowing
When you’re sending documents back and forth between external partners and your internal team, consistency matters more than you think. PDFs make this a whole lot easier by locking in formatting so things don’t get weird depending on the device or platform someone’s using. What makes them even more versatile now is the ability to mark them up in-browser, which saves time and avoids endless email threads. The impact of editing PDFs on documents is that your workflow stays clean, your comments stay visible, and nobody has to guess what needs to be changed.
Chemistry Beats Chops in the Long Run
Skills get people in the door, but chemistry keeps projects from imploding. You could hire a marketing genius, but if they don’t click with your team or they bulldoze your brand voice, it won’t matter. You need people who get how you work, who can push you without steamrolling you, and who understand nuance. Set up a real conversation before you commit. Not just a pitch. Ask them to walk you through a decision they made that didn’t work out, and how they adjusted. Their answer will tell you more than any portfolio ever could.
The Best Hires Ask You Tough Questions
If you’re talking to someone who says yes too fast, back away. The right external hire will make you a little uncomfortable—not in a disrespectful way, but in a way that reveals blind spots you didn’t know were holding you back. They’ll ask why you’re targeting a certain audience, what data you're using to define success, why that ad headline matters. These are people who’ve seen inside a hundred businesses and know which levers actually move the needle. And they won’t just let you waste money to keep you happy. That alone is worth every dollar.
Freelancer or Agency? Think About Control
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer here, but there are trade-offs you need to be honest about. Agencies can offer full teams, a polished process, and multiple skill sets under one roof. But you might lose a little control or get passed between account managers. Freelancers offer more flexibility and usually work faster, but they’ll have limits on what they can take on. It depends on how hands-on you want to be. If you want full control over every decision, a freelancer might suit you better. If you want someone to take the reins, an agency with a strong track record of leadership might be the way to go.
Don’t Skip the Test Project Phase
No matter how glowing the reviews or promising the intro call, always start with a test project. Give them a small piece of the puzzle—a week’s worth of social content, one landing page rewrite, a short email sequence—and pay them for it. See how they communicate, how fast they move, how deep they go into the strategy. You’ll learn more from ten days of actual collaboration than a hundred hours of portfolio scrolling. And if it’s not the right fit, you’ll save yourself from a full-blown engagement that never had a shot.
You Still Have to Lead
Here’s the hard truth a lot of business owners dodge: no matter how talented the person you hire is, you’re still on the hook for leadership. External professionals don’t fix broken internal culture. They won’t create alignment out of chaos or read your mind about where things are going. You need to brief well, give consistent feedback, and create enough structure that they’re set up to win. Even the best hires need your attention and clarity. If you treat the hire like a silver bullet, you’ll always end up frustrated and broke.
At the end of the day, the right external hires don’t just execute, they unlock something bigger. They help you stop spinning your wheels and start seeing real traction. But you won’t find them by skimming Fiverr listings or picking whoever your buddy used last year. You’ve got to go in with purpose, ask hard questions, and trust your gut once you see real work. The payoff is a team you can count on, one that pushes your sales and marketing goals from rough sketch to real momentum. So, start looking—not just for help, but for the kind of help that actually changes the game.
Discover the vibrant community and endless opportunities with the Brainerd Lakes Chamber of Commerce. Whether you’re looking to grow your business or explore local events, we’ve got you covered!